Diamond Index team profile

Seton Hall Prep

County—ConferenceSECGroup—Head coach—

Season record23-42011-2012

DI Score87.8

State Rank#3

Run Differential+163

Strength of Schedule0.7

Roster23

Team wRC+108

Team PIT17.8

Season context

Record & Schedule Profile

27 completed games

Conference Record16-3SEC

Division Record—No division listed

Runs per Game8.59232 total runs

Runs Allowed per Game2.5669 total allowed

Home Record13-316 home games

Away Record10-111 road games

Tournament Record3-25 tournament games

Current StreakL1Most recent completed games

vs. DI Top 250-11 games

vs. DI Top 503-14 games

Average Opponent DI60.3Full completed schedule

Strength of Schedule0.7Opponent quality adjustment

Best WinMontclair3–1 · Opponent DI 72.7

Worst LossNutley2–4 · Opponent DI 66.7

Season results

Schedule & Games

27 games

Jun 1vs

DDelbartonNJSIAA Tournament, Semifinal Round, Non-Public AL6–7Box score →May 29vs

BCBergen CatholicNJSIAA Tournament, Quarterfinal Round, Non-Public AW12–2Box score →May 24at

NNutleyL2–4Box score →May 18vs

WEWest EssexW11–1Box score →May 17at

WOWest OrangeW2–0Box score →

Rating neighbors

Similar Teams

DI · AdjO · AdjD · SOS

GCGloucester CatholicTri-County

DI 90.29.14 AdjO2.05 AdjD88% match

WWestfieldUCC

DI 84.39.31 AdjO3.61 AdjD88% match

RBRed Bank CatholicShore

DI 78.88.79 AdjO3.73 AdjD83% match

CCranfordUCC

DI 86.08.16 AdjO2.64 AdjD82% match

SASt. AugustineCape-Atlantic

DI 78.58.13 AdjO3.20 AdjD78% match

IImmaculataSkyland

DI 76.58.73 AdjO4.09 AdjD78% match

Team production

Batting Statistics

18 hitters

#	Player	PA	H	HR	R	RBI	SB	AVG	OBP	SLG	OPS	wOBA	wRC+	Off
1	Mark Venice	99	34	3	28	28	8	.430	.545	.671	1.216	.523	133	7.5
2	Mike Manfredonia	3	0	0	21	0	6	.000	.667	.000	.667	.467	105	1.2
3	D J Link	103	34	2	2	23	0	.391	.485	.563	1.049	.462	102	0.4
4	Nick Mascelli	102	33	0	31	28	14	.398	.510	.518	1.028	.460	101	3.1
5	Frank Maldonado	87	26	0	23	21	14	.382	.517	.456	.973	.444	93	1.8
6	Tim Hoehn

Run prevention

Pitching Statistics

8 pitchers

#	Player	IP	H	R	ER	BB	SO	ERA	WHIP	K/7	BB/7	FIP	PIT
1	Bobby Morgenroth	46.7	33	16	12	12	38	1.80	0.96	5.70	1.80	2.50	8.0
2	Mike Winschuh	10.3	8	2	0	5	2	0.00	1.26	1.35	3.39	4.16	4.4
3	Cody McCallum	18.0	14	7	5	15	14	1.94	1.61	5.44	5.83	4.21	2.7
4	Tim Hofmann	20.7	12	7	7	13	22	2.37	1.21	7.45	4.40	3.00	1.9
5	Joe DiLorenzo	2.3	1	0	0	2	4	0.00	1.29	12.00	6.00	2.24	1.0
6	Michael Sheppard III

Year-to-year development

Program Trends

Metric

Wins by season23Latest · 2025–2026

30231580

2011, 222012, 232013, 302014, 252015, 272016, 282017, 262018, 242019, 222021, 202022, 212023, 152024, 252025, 222026, 23

201120122013201420152016201720182019202120222023202420252026

201122201223201330201425201527201628201726201824201922202120202221202315202425202522202623

All-time history

Record Book

Season · Career · Single Game

#	Player	Team	Season	Hits
1	Alex Baratta	Seton Hall Prep	2014–2015	48
2	Matt O'Neill	Seton Hall Prep	2014–2015	45
3	Nick Mascelli	Seton Hall Prep	2012–2013	43
4	Jordan Burwell	Seton Hall Prep	2025–2026	41
5	Michael Bravette	Seton Hall Prep	2023–2024	40
6	Frank Maldonado	Seton Hall Prep	2012–2013	39
7	William Mahala	Seton Hall Prep	2023–2024	39
8	Mike DeRenzi	Seton Hall Prep	2013–2014	37
9	Robert Fonseca	Seton Hall Prep	2010–2011	37
10	Alex Baratta	Seton Hall Prep	2013–2014	36
11	Chris Maldonado	Seton Hall Prep	2020–2021	36
12	Matt Cianci	Seton Hall Prep	2010–2011	36
13	Henry Ayers	Seton Hall Prep	2024–2025	35
14	Ryan Sprock	Seton Hall Prep	2020–2021	35
15	Stephan Halibej	Seton Hall Prep	2010–2011	35
16	D J Link	Seton Hall Prep	2011–2012	34
17	Mark Venice	Seton Hall Prep	2011–2012	34
18	Mark Venice	Seton Hall Prep	2013–2014	34
19	Ryan Sheppard	Seton Hall Prep	2017–2018	34
20	Ryan Sprock	Seton Hall Prep	2021–2022	34
21	Tyler Brosius	Seton Hall Prep	2014–2015	34
22	D J Link	Seton Hall Prep	2010–2011	33
23	Jack Zyska	Seton Hall Prep	2015–2016	33
24	Nick Mascelli	Seton Hall Prep	2011–2012	33
25	Ryan Toohers	Seton Hall Prep	2015–2016	33

#	Player	Grade	Position	PA	IP
#10	Bobby Morgenroth	Senior	P	—	46.7
#22	Brandon Sharp	Senior	C	4	—
#7	Cody McCallum	Senior	OF, P	74	18.0
#15	D J Link	Senior	C	103	—
#8	Joe DiLorenzo	Senior	P	—	2.3
#4	Marcel Morales	Senior	OF	11	—
#6	Mark Mari	Senior	OF	78	—
#3	Matthew Perez	Senior	IF	7	—
#13	Michael Sheppard III	Senior	P	—	42.0
#11	Tim Hofmann	Senior	P	—	20.7
#1	Ty Blankmeyer	Senior	IF	99	—
#24	C J Diana	Junior	C	1	—
#12	Collin Nordstrom	Junior	OF, P	25	—
#5	Frank Maldonado	Junior	OF	87	—
#9	Kevin Mahala	Junior	IF, P	91	7.3
#27	Mike Manfredonia	Junior	OF	3	—
#25	Mike Muha	Junior	1B	4	—
#21	Mike Winschuh	Junior	P	—	10.3
#2	Nick Mascelli	Junior	IF	102	—
#20	Pat Gardner	Junior	C	7	—
#26	Tim Hoehn	Junior	SS, P	96	—
#28	Mark Venice	Sophomore	P, OF	99	—
#14	Michael Sgaramella	Sophomore	P, 1B	4	22.7