NJ Sports Index
OverviewDiamondPitchGridironCourt
NJ
DDiamond IndexNew Jersey Baseball
DailyLeadersTeamsRankingsScoresComparePredictorStandingsGlossary
RP
Diamond Index team profile

Rutgers Prep

County—ConferenceSkylandGroup—Head coach—
Season record12-102011-2012
DI Score59.0
State Rank#129
Run Differential-1
Strength of Schedule0.5
Roster12
Team wRC+134
Team PIT-5.5
Season context

Record & Schedule Profile

22 completed games
Conference Record5-6Skyland
Division Record—No division listed
Runs per Game5.77127 total runs
Runs Allowed per Game5.27116 total allowed
Home Record2-13 home games
Away Record10-919 road games
Tournament Record5-16 tournament games
Current StreakW4Most recent completed games
vs. DI Top 250-44 games
vs. DI Top 500-44 games
Average Opponent DI57.4Full completed schedule
Strength of Schedule0.5Opponent quality adjustment
Best WinMontclair Kimberley4–2 · Opponent DI 67.1
Worst LossFranklin5–6 · Opponent DI 35.1
Season results

Schedule & Games

22 games
May 17atGSGill St. Bernard'sPrep B Tournament, Final RoundW9–1Box score →May 16atNANewark AcademyPrep B Tournament, Semifinal RoundW7–2Box score →May 11atSBSouth BrunswickW6–5Box score →May 10atMKMontclair KimberleyPrep B Tournament, First RoundW4–2Box score →May 7atFFranklinL5–6Box score →
Rating neighbors

Similar Teams

DI · AdjO · AdjD · SOS
PPennsaukenBCSL
DI 60.45.89 AdjO4.61 AdjD95% match
HPHanover ParkNJAC
DI 58.66.01 AdjO4.70 AdjD92% match
EHEgg HarborCape-Atlantic
DI 56.45.69 AdjO5.06 AdjD91% match
MMorristown-BeardNJAC
DI 59.26.09 AdjO4.60 AdjD91% match
OOakcrestCape-Atlantic
DI 55.05.96 AdjO5.39 AdjD90% match
EEasternOlympic
DI 61.06.12 AdjO4.29 AdjD90% match
Team production

Batting Statistics

12 hitters
#PlayerPAHHRRRBISBAVGOBPSLGOPSwOBAwRC+Off
1Michael Coiro1101001.0001.0001.0002.000.9003230.4
2Anthony Brocato4724620193.585.6381.3171.955.78726614.6
3Mike Klinger5131013195.646.667.7501.417.6271858.7
4Malcolm Kelsey5224212112.522.577.8041.381.5901676.6
5Paul Nemergut381801372.600.684.6331.318.5841644.7
6Colby Smith
Run prevention

Pitching Statistics

5 pitchers
#PlayerIPHRERBBSOERAWHIPK/7BB/7FIPPIT
1Mike Klinger39.0269814461.441.038.262.511.978.7
2Perry Moorstein1.7210000.001.200.000.003.100.7
3Malcolm Kelsey35.345211820193.571.843.763.963.72-2.9
4Brandon Hameier6.01077618.172.671.177.006.27-4.4
5Jeff McHale24.330201816155.181.894.324.604.21-7.6
Year-to-year development

Program Trends

Wins by season17Latest · 2025–2026
30231580
2011, 142012, 122013, 172014, 112015, 92016, 152017, 162018, 82019, 182021, 132022, 192023, 142024, 122025, 142026, 17
201120122013201420152016201720182019202120222023202420252026
2011142012122013172014112015920161520171620188201918202113202219202314202412202514202617
All-time history

Record Book

Season · Career · Single Game
Team record book
#PlayerTeamSeasonHits
1Malcolm KelseyRutgers Prep2012–201353
2Spencer DigginsRutgers Prep2012–201349
3Anthony BrocatoRutgers Prep2012–201346
4Anthony KuzmenkoRutgers Prep2016–201744
5Anthony KuzmenkoRutgers Prep2015–201643
6Kyle JohnsRutgers Prep2018–201943
7Anthony BrocatoRutgers Prep2013–201442
8Jack SandstedtRutgers Prep2018–201942
9Benjamin CuccoloRutgers Prep2018–201939
10Paul NemergutRutgers Prep2012–201338
11Ryan WithumRutgers Prep2018–201938
12Andrew CrystalRutgers Prep2016–201737
13Alex PerezRutgers Prep2025–202636
14Andrew ParisiRutgers Prep2021–202236
15Ethan NepomucenoRutgers Prep2022–202336
16Evan LaubRutgers Prep2023–202435
17Colby SmithRutgers Prep2012–201334
18Daniel SchantzRutgers Prep2015–201634
19Justin HenryRutgers Prep2016–201734
20Justin HenryRutgers Prep2015–201633
21Kyle JohnsRutgers Prep2017–201833
22Matt Von RoemerRutgers Prep2013–201433
23Zach FronioRutgers Prep2022–202333
24Nicholas PizzieRutgers Prep2021–202232
25Andrew ParisiRutgers Prep2022–202331
May 5atIImmaculataSomerset County Tournament, Quarterfinal RoundL3–4Box score →
May 4atWWestfieldL0–10Box score →
May 1atRRidgeW3–2Box score →
Apr 28atGSGill St. Bernard'sSomerset County Tournament, Second RoundW9–2Box score →
Apr 27vsPDPrinceton DayL3–18Box score →
Apr 25atBBridgewater-RaritanL1–12Box score →
Apr 21vsMManvilleSomerset County Tournament, First RoundW13–0Box score →
Apr 20atIImmaculataL2–4Box score →
Apr 18atGSGill St. Bernard'sL4–5Box score →
Apr 17atMMiddlesexL7–12Box score →
Apr 16atHHunW10–4Box score →
Apr 15vsWPWhippany ParkW4–1Box score →
Apr 14atPPingryL0–8Box score →
Apr 11atPPeddieW7–6Box score →
Apr 10atMMorristownL4–6Box score →
Apr 4atPPenningtonW9–4Box score →
Apr 3atSSomervilleW17–2Box score →
Player directory

Roster

12 players
#PlayerGradePositionPAIP
#28Brandon HameierSeniorOF426.0
#26Jeff McHaleSeniorP3724.3
#13Mike KlingerSeniorIF, P5139.0
#14Perry MoorsteinSeniorIF, P41.7
#18Colby SmithJuniorC50—
#52Malcolm KelseyJuniorIF, P5235.3
#23Paul NemergutJuniorIF38—
#27Spencer DigginsJuniorOF, P46—
#34Anthony BrocatoSophomoreOF47—
#36Matt Von RoemerSophomoreIF, OF38—
#55Jackson SchuetzFreshmanSS, 3B7—
#17Michael CoiroFreshman1B, C1—
50
20
0
10
9
0
.500
.600
.650
1.250
.548
146
4.0
7Jeff McHale37151790.441.486.5881.075.4731080.5
8Matt Von Roemer381301230.382.447.500.947.42182-1.1
9Jackson Schuetz730311.429.429.429.857.38664-0.2
10Brandon Hameier42130933.342.405.395.799.36453-2.9
11Spencer Diggins4612011123.293.370.366.735.33739-4.4
12Perry Moorstein400000.000.000.000.000.000-131-1.6