NJ Sports Index
OverviewDiamondPitchGridironCourt
NJ
DDiamond IndexNew Jersey Baseball
DailyLeadersTeamsRankingsScoresComparePredictorStandingsGlossary
RP
Diamond Index team profile

Rutgers Prep

County—ConferenceSkylandGroup—Head coach—
Season record16-142016-2017
DI Score60.5
State Rank#123
Run Differential+31
Strength of Schedule0.6
Roster22
Team wRC+98
Team PIT-11.8
Season context

Record & Schedule Profile

30 completed games
Conference Record10-10Skyland
Division Record—No division listed
Runs per Game5.60168 total runs
Runs Allowed per Game4.10123 total allowed
Home Record10-515 home games
Away Record6-915 road games
Tournament Record8-210 tournament games
Current StreakL1Most recent completed games
vs. DI Top 250-22 games
vs. DI Top 500-44 games
Average Opponent DI57.6Full completed schedule
Strength of Schedule0.6Opponent quality adjustment
Best WinWatchung Hills2–1 · Opponent DI 67.9
Worst LossFranklin8–11 · Opponent DI 40.8
Season results

Schedule & Games

30 games
Jun 2atSRSt. RoseNJSIAA Tournament, Semifinal Round, Non-Public BL0–6Box score →May 31vsHCHoly CrossNJSIAA Tournament, Quarterfinal Round, Non-Public BW9–2Box score →May 26vsMDMater DeiNJSIAA Tournament, First Round, Non-Public BW4–3Box score →May 24atDVDelaware ValleyL2–3Box score →May 23atIImmaculataL2–3Box score →
Rating neighbors

Similar Teams

DI · AdjO · AdjD · SOS
SPSouth PlainfieldGMC
DI 62.35.79 AdjO4.44 AdjD95% match
VVernonNJAC
DI 62.95.91 AdjO4.45 AdjD94% match
SSomervilleSkyland
DI 62.25.56 AdjO4.06 AdjD94% match
NHNorthern HighlandsBig North
DI 63.36.09 AdjO4.38 AdjD93% match
RBRed Bank RegionalShore
DI 58.35.43 AdjO4.37 AdjD91% match
KKingswayTri-County
DI 56.25.83 AdjO4.88 AdjD91% match
Team production

Batting Statistics

22 hitters
#PlayerPAHHRRRBISBAVGOBPSLGOPSwOBAwRC+Off
1Hemanth Gundala1100101.0001.0001.0002.000.9003610.5
2Josh Kutner840320.800.875.8001.675.7122662.4
3Zach Olson200000.0001.000.0001.000.7002600.6
4Cam Withum320320.667.667.6671.333.6002100.6
5Justin Henry1103410253314.366.464.7631.227.51116515.5
6Anthony Kuzmenko
Run prevention

Pitching Statistics

9 pitchers
#PlayerIPHRERBBSOERAWHIPK/7BB/7FIPPIT
1Sam Beck54.7391199651.150.888.321.151.3814.4
2John Langenfeld20.7251457181.691.556.102.372.523.9
3Andre Scheflen1.7200100.001.800.004.204.900.7
4Anthony Kuzmenko40.74617178452.931.337.751.381.480.4
5Ryan Withum10.71266273.941.314.591.312.35-1.4
6Jack Withum2.0
Year-to-year development

Program Trends

Wins by season17Latest · 2025–2026
30231580
2011, 142012, 122013, 172014, 112015, 92016, 152017, 162018, 82019, 182021, 132022, 192023, 142024, 122025, 142026, 17
201120122013201420152016201720182019202120222023202420252026
2011142012122013172014112015920161520171620188201918202113202219202314202412202514202617
All-time history

Record Book

Season · Career · Single Game
Team record book
#PlayerTeamSeasonHits
1Malcolm KelseyRutgers Prep2012–201353
2Spencer DigginsRutgers Prep2012–201349
3Anthony BrocatoRutgers Prep2012–201346
4Anthony KuzmenkoRutgers Prep2016–201744
5Anthony KuzmenkoRutgers Prep2015–201643
6Kyle JohnsRutgers Prep2018–201943
7Anthony BrocatoRutgers Prep2013–201442
8Jack SandstedtRutgers Prep2018–201942
9Benjamin CuccoloRutgers Prep2018–201939
10Paul NemergutRutgers Prep2012–201338
11Ryan WithumRutgers Prep2018–201938
12Andrew CrystalRutgers Prep2016–201737
13Alex PerezRutgers Prep2025–202636
14Andrew ParisiRutgers Prep2021–202236
15Ethan NepomucenoRutgers Prep2022–202336
16Evan LaubRutgers Prep2023–202435
17Colby SmithRutgers Prep2012–201334
18Daniel SchantzRutgers Prep2015–201634
19Justin HenryRutgers Prep2016–201734
20Justin HenryRutgers Prep2015–201633
21Kyle JohnsRutgers Prep2017–201833
22Matt Von RoemerRutgers Prep2013–201433
23Zach FronioRutgers Prep2022–202333
24Nicholas PizzieRutgers Prep2021–202232
25Andrew ParisiRutgers Prep2022–202331
May 20atBBernardsW2–0Box score →
May 17vsOOratoryW8–0Box score →
May 16vsNANewark AcademyPrep-B Tournament, Semifinal RoundL2–8Box score →
May 15atMMontgomerySomerset County Tournament, Final RoundW7–2Box score →
May 12atBBridgewater-RaritanL4–5Box score →
May 11vsWWardlaw-HartridgePrep-B Tournament, First RoundW14–4Box score →
May 9atBBridgewater-RaritanSomerset County Tournament, Semifinal RoundW12–2Box score →
May 6atWHWatchung HillsSomerset County Tournament, Quarterfinal RoundW2–1Box score →
May 6vsCCCalvary Christian (Old Bridge)W14–0Box score →
May 4atSSomervilleL5–6Box score →
May 2atVVoorheesL6–9Box score →
Apr 29atBBernardsSomerset County Tournament, Second RoundW3–1Box score →
Apr 28vsFFranklinL8–11Box score →
Apr 27vsDVDelaware ValleyW9–8Box score →
Apr 24vsPPingryW5–0Box score →
Apr 23vsWPWhippany ParkW3–0Box score →
Apr 22vsMManvilleSomerset County Tournament, First RoundW16–0Box score →
Apr 20atWHWarren HillsL2–12Box score →
Apr 18vsSSomervilleL0–8Box score →
Apr 15atMMillburnL1–2Box score →
Apr 12vsVVoorheesL1–5Box score →
Apr 10atGSGill St. Bernard'sW8–1Box score →
Apr 8atSBSouth BrunswickL11–13Box score →
Apr 8vsMMontgomeryL2–5Box score →
Apr 5vsBBernardsW6–3Box score →
Player directory

Roster

22 players
#PlayerGradePositionPAIP
#54Abhinav PenumudiSeniorOF9—
#18Andrew CrystalSeniorC, 3B109—
#27Anthony KuzmenkoSeniorSS, P11640.7
#11Guilio VetrianiSeniorOF74—
#45Jack WithumSeniorIF, P762.0
#14John LangenfeldSeniorIF, P9720.7
#37Josh KutnerSeniorOF, P823.7
#5Justin HenrySeniorOF, P110—
#28Lorenzo GerosoSeniorP, IF8946.3
#44Sam BeckSenior1B, P10354.7
#57Spencer FinkSeniorP, OF403.0
#6Brian CooperJuniorIF, P3—
#43Tyler Chandross-CohenJuniorOF2—
#7Zach OlsonJuniorIF, P2—
#54Cam WithumSophomore2B, OF3—
#40Hemanth GundalaSophomoreOF1—
#17Kyle JohnsSophomore3B, C90—
#22Ryan WithumSophomoreOF, P510.7
#24Andre ScheflenFreshmanP, IF81.7
#19Matt ThomasFreshmanP, IF1—
—Matthew FoxworthFreshman1—
#53Robert Rittenhouse—4—
116
44
3
32
17
5
.436
.509
.634
1.142
.497
158
13.0
7Andre Scheflen830253.429.500.5711.071.4751471.3
8Andrew Crystal10937118210.374.431.475.906.4061122.3
9Sam Beck10330513230.313.359.573.932.4011091.8
10Abhinav Penumudi930305.375.444.375.819.378981.0
11Spencer Fink4091731.273.400.424.824.37295-0.2
12Kyle Johns9022110130.282.378.333.711.33073-4.2
13Jack Withum761401261.222.355.286.641.30762-4.9
14John Langenfeld972001161.244.361.280.641.30661-6.4
15Guilio Vetriani74911362.161.365.232.597.30058-5.1
16Ryan Withum500210.000.400.000.400.28048-0.5
17Lorenzo Geroso891727180.198.225.326.550.24329-11.1
18Brian Cooper300000.000.333.000.333.23324-0.4
19Tyler Chandross-Cohen200000.000.000.000.000.000-93-0.7
20Matt Thomas100000.000.000.000.000.000-93-0.3
21Matthew Foxworth100110.000.000.000.000.000-93-0.3
22Robert Rittenhouse400000.000.000.000.000.000-93-1.4
3
3
3
3
0
10.50
3.00
0.00
10.50
9.10
-2.1
7Josh Kutner23.73618157114.441.823.252.073.06-4.9
8Lorenzo Geroso46.35940319154.681.472.271.363.23-11.1
9Spencer Fink3.0713139330.335.337.0021.0012.10-11.7