NJ Sports Index
OverviewDiamondPitchGridironCourt
NJ
DDiamond IndexNew Jersey Baseball
DailyLeadersTeamsRankingsScoresComparePredictorStandingsGlossary
TR
Diamond Index team profile

Toms River South

County—ConferenceShoreGroup—Head coach—
Season record22-52016-2017
DI Score76.3
State Rank#19
Run Differential+96
Strength of Schedule0.7
Roster16
Team wRC+116
Team PIT30.1
Season context

Record & Schedule Profile

27 completed games
Conference Record21-4Shore
Division Record—No division listed
Runs per Game6.04163 total runs
Runs Allowed per Game2.4867 total allowed
Home Record15-419 home games
Away Record7-18 road games
Tournament Record6-39 tournament games
Current StreakL2Most recent completed games
vs. DI Top 252-24 games
vs. DI Top 503-36 games
Average Opponent DI59.9Full completed schedule
Strength of Schedule0.7Opponent quality adjustment
Best WinToms River North3–2 · Opponent DI 73.2
Worst LossJackson Memorial1–2 · Opponent DI 55.5
Season results

Schedule & Games

27 games
Jun 1vsRBRed Bank CatholicShore Conference Tournament, Semifinal RoundL2–3Box score →May 31vsAAllentownNJSIAA Tournament, Semifinal Round, Group 3L3–4Box score →May 26vsBTBrick TownshipNJSIAA Tournament, Quarterfinal Round, Group 3W2–1Box score →May 24vsPPinelandsShore Conference Tournament, Quarterfinal RoundW1–0Box score →May 23vs
Rating neighbors

Similar Teams

DI · AdjO · AdjD · SOS
EEasternOlympic
DI 78.77.35 AdjO2.70 AdjD93% match
TRToms River NorthShore
DI 73.27.26 AdjO3.43 AdjD93% match
CCranfordUCC
DI 72.77.25 AdjO3.30 AdjD92% match
LLenapeOlympic
DI 72.77.40 AdjO3.41 AdjD91% match
RRandolphNJAC
DI 77.37.44 AdjO2.84 AdjD90% match
MMillvilleCape-Atlantic
DI 69.56.81 AdjO3.17 AdjD89% match
Team production

Batting Statistics

14 hitters
#PlayerPAHHRRRBISBAVGOBPSLGOPSwOBAwRC+Off
1TJ Scuderi8729424256.392.483.7031.185.50216010.8
2Justin Fall762619203.400.487.5541.041.4591385.9
3Matt Shiffer8836023149.444.489.5191.007.4511347.2
4Dylan Danelson6322012910.407.492.481.974.4401295.2
5Matt Fitzpatrick7828016170.389.436.514.950.4221202.8
6Tom Campo
Run prevention

Pitching Statistics

8 pitchers
#PlayerIPHRERBBSOERAWHIPK/7BB/7FIPPIT
1Justin Fall54.339171526601.931.207.733.352.448.3
2TJ Scuderi37.0351189401.511.197.571.701.917.9
3Matt Shiffer22.724746171.241.325.251.852.795.7
4Matt Hartshorn25.0201185122.241.003.361.402.862.7
5Nico Gonnella9.71162221.451.341.451.453.622.1
6Colin Mackle
Year-to-year development

Program Trends

Wins by season18Latest · 2025–2026
30231580
2011, 192012, 222013, 182014, 152015, 192016, 222017, 222018, 122019, 132021, 122022, 132023, 102024, 52025, 182026, 18
201120122013201420152016201720182019202120222023202420252026
20111920122220131820141520151920162220172220181220191320211220221320231020245202518202618
All-time history

Record Book

Season · Career · Single Game
Team record book
#PlayerTeamSeasonHits
1Jaden GeremiaToms River South2025–202642
2Jaden GeremiaToms River South2024–202536
3Matt ShifferToms River South2016–201736
4Russell Messler JuniorToms River South2012–201334
5TJ ScuderiToms River South2016–201729
6Matt FitzpatrickToms River South2016–201728
7Justin FallToms River South2016–201726
8Andrew SchmidtToms River South2025–202625
9Ben Montenegro JuniorToms River South2015–201625
10Matt Shiffer JuniorToms River South2015–201625
11Russell MesslerToms River South2011–201225
12TJ ScuderiToms River South2017–201825
13Tyler Wisnewski SeniorToms River South2015–201625
14Christian MascaroToms River South2024–202524
15Colin MackleToms River South2018–201924
16Matt Hartshorn SeniorToms River South2018–201924
17Brett RankinToms River South2024–202523
18Jared Kwicinski SeniorToms River South2016–201723
19MIkey ErliToms River South2021–202223
20TJ Scuderi SophomoreToms River South2015–201623
21Ben McEwanToms River South2024–202522
22Ben MontenegroToms River South2016–201722
23Dylan DanelsonToms River South2016–201722
24Jake RyanToms River South2014–201522
25Brett RankinToms River South2025–202621
LB
Long Branch
NJSIAA Tournament, First Round, Group 3
W
7–0
Box score →
May 20vsJLJackson LibertyShore Conference Tournament, First RoundW11–8Box score →
May 17vsLLaceyW4–3Box score →
May 16vsTRToms River NorthOcean County Tournament, Semifinal RoundL2–5Box score →
May 15atBTBrick TownshipW8–3Box score →
May 12vsJLJackson LibertyL1–3Box score →
May 11vsCRCentral RegionalOcean County Tournament, Quarterfinal RoundW6–3Box score →
May 10vsBMBrick MemorialW5–1Box score →
May 8atCRCentral RegionalW11–1Box score →
May 6atTRToms River EastOcean County Tournament, First RoundW3–0Box score →
May 4vsSSouthernW7–3Box score →
May 2vsTRToms River EastW7–6Box score →
Apr 29vsBBayonneW10–3Box score →
Apr 28vsBTBrick TownshipW4–2Box score →
Apr 26vsTRToms River NorthW3–2Box score →
Apr 24atJMJackson MemorialL1–2Box score →
Apr 20atBMBrick MemorialW9–2Box score →
Apr 18vsCRCentral RegionalW6–3Box score →
Apr 17atTRToms River NorthW11–2Box score →
Apr 13atSSouthernW9–1Box score →
Apr 12atTRToms River EastW13–2Box score →
Apr 8vsBBarnegatW15–4Box score →
Apr 5vsJMJackson MemorialW2–0Box score →
Player directory

Roster

16 players
#PlayerGradePositionPAIP
#14Ben MontenegroSenior3B88—
#37Connor LeathermanSeniorC52—
#13Dylan DanelsonSeniorOF63—
—Jared KwicinskiSenior77—
#30Justin FallSeniorP, DH7654.3
#9Matt FitzpatrickSenior1B78—
#16Matt ShifferSenior2B, P8822.7
#6Tom CampoSeniorSS78—
#4Nico GonnellaJuniorP, 1B—9.7
#1TJ ScuderiJuniorOF, P8737.0
—Tom SpiwakJunior—12.0
#18Colin MackleSophomoreOF, P219.3
#2Jordan ErbeSophomoreIF, P43.0
#10Matt HartshornSophomoreP, 1B425.0
—Michael LazarroSophomore1—
#23Sam ConoverSophomoreOF, C1—
78
20
2
14
12
0
.303
.410
.455
.865
.387
102
0.3
7Ben Montenegro8822113110.289.386.421.807.36491-1.4
8Jared Kwicinski7723017135.315.351.425.775.34380-1.4
9Connor Leatherman52120020.261.346.326.672.31264-3.3
10Colin Mackle2140151.200.238.300.538.24329-2.4
11Jordan Erbe410400.250.250.250.500.22520-0.6
12Matt Hartshorn410000.250.250.250.500.22520-0.6
13Michael Lazarro100000.000.000.000.000.000-93-0.3
14Sam Conover1001601.000.000.000.000.000-93-0.1
9.3
7
3
2
6
3
1.50
1.39
2.25
4.50
4.39
2.0
7Tom Spiwak12.011648142.331.588.174.673.271.1
8Jordan Erbe3.0111112.330.672.332.334.430.3